Week 5
Pregame
Kickoff is Thursday night, Tampa Bay at Dallas, lineups lock at six, and it is the first bye week of the season: Kansas City and Carolina are off, and four of you still have their players sitting in your starting lineups like the schedule is a rumor. Four teams are 3-1, Joey is 0-4 with the most points against in the league, and the defending champion is starting a quarterback who has already been ruled Out.
Week 4 Postgame
Read the full recap →Three of the six favorites lost, the closest game of the week came down to four hundredths of a point, and Chris put up the highest score in the league while sitting at 1-3 because God is not real. Also, nine of you couldn't be bothered to make six pick'em selections, which is its own kind of answer.
- Jarrod 114.9 · Morgan 112.4Morgan Scores Thirty Under and Loses
- Ryan 147.5 · Beth 147.5Beth Benched LaPorta. Beth Is Named LaPorta-Potty.
- Chris 155.1 · Lauren 118.8League's Best Score, League's Worst Luck
- Nicole 149.4 · Jared 107.7Jared Gets Forty-Three Under, Deservedly
- Holli 135.3 · Ben 92.9Ben Benched Burrow, Scored League Low
- Ally 126.7 · Joey 103.9Joey Is 0-4. Say It Out Loud.
Moves
- Wed Oct 7Morgan picked up Matt Gay (K), dropped Harrison Butker
- Wed Oct 7Ryan picked up Keon Coleman (WR)
- Wed Oct 7Morgan picked up Evan McPherson (K), dropped Matt Gay
- Wed Oct 7Morgan picked up Cincinnati Bengals (DEF), dropped Cleveland Browns
- Wed Oct 7Jarrod picked up Malik Washington (WR), dropped Rashod Bateman
- Wed Oct 7Ryan picked up Will Shipley (RB)
- Wed Sep 30Ben picked up Keaton Mitchell (RB), dropped De'Von Achane
- Wed Sep 30Jarrod picked up Dontayvion Wicks (WR), dropped Isaiah Likely
- Wed Sep 30Lauren picked up Drake Maye (QB), dropped Malik Willis
- Wed Sep 30Lauren picked up Woody Marks (RB), dropped Chris Rodriguez
- Wed Sep 30Ryan picked up nobody, dropped Dallas Goedert
- Wed Sep 30Lauren picked up Pittsburgh Steelers (DEF), dropped Green Bay Packers
- Wed Sep 30Beth picked up Kalif Raymond (WR), dropped Kyle Pitts
- Tue Oct 6Ryan claimed Jacksonville Jaguars (DEF), dropped Minnesota Vikings
Loading live numbers from Sleeper…

Jarrod Has The Fewest Points In The League
408.74 points for, dead last, behind the winless commissioner, and somehow 2-2 because the schedule has been carrying him.
Jarrod has scored 408.74 points. Not the fewest among the bad teams, the fewest in the entire goddamn league, less than the 0-4 commissioner, less than Chris, less than everybody, and he is 2-2 because this schedule has been doing him favors it stops doing Thursday. Ryan has 590.66. That is a hundred and eighty-two more points than Jarrod and it is not close to a conversation. Ryan also swept him 2-0 last year by a combined eighty-one, then went home and this week added Will Shipley and Keon Coleman without dropping a soul, because he has roster space and Jarrod has Malik Washington starting at receiver hours after signing him. Dak, CeeDee Lamb and Brandon Aubrey are all in the Thursday opener, fifty of Ryan's points banked before Jarrod has read his own matchup. Ryan by nineteen.
Ryan 2-0 head to head in 2025, 146.12-111.74 and 132.56-75.6. Projected 149.6 to 130.8, Ryan by 18.8. Jarrod: 408.74 points for, last in the league. Ryan: 590.66, first. Jarrod's starters include two Questionable.Tale of the tape
| 149.6 | Projected | 130.8 |
| B+ | Draft grade | B+ |
| 9-5 | 2025 record | 3-11 |
| 6th | 2025 finish | 12th |
| 122.9 | 2025 avg | 106.1 |
| 0 | Empty slots | 0 |
Morgan Cut A Kicker And Re-Signed Him
Last week this page said she was winning by leaving the room. She read it, lost, and panicked at a vending machine.
Last week this page said Morgan hadn't touched her team since draft night and was winning by doing absolutely fuck-all. She read that, lost, and spent this morning making three moves. The Browns defense she signed last Thursday, dropped for Cincinnati's. Matt Gay, dropped for Evan McPherson. Then Harrison Butker dropped to sign Matt Gay back. She cut a kicker and re-signed him inside the same hour, which is not roster management, that is a woman standing at a vending machine hitting the same button and getting angrier. And she is still favored, because Lauren is 1-3, on an L3, has 579.28 points against her, and is starting Woody Marks at 11.8 with Breece Hall sitting on her bench at 17.6. Woody fucking Marks. A 10-4 runner-up last year is now losing to churn. Morgan by eight.
Morgan won the only 2025 meeting 137.02-105.82. Projected 128.3 to 120.0, Morgan by 8.3. Morgan: three transactions this morning, 351.62 points against, fewest in the league. Lauren: L3, 579.28 against, Breece Hall benched at 17.6.Tale of the tape
| 120.0 | Projected | 128.3 |
| C+ | Draft grade | B- |
| 10-4 | 2025 record | 7-7 |
| 2nd | 2025 finish | 7th |
| 114.3 | 2025 avg | 128.3 |
| 0 | Empty slots | 0 |
Lineup alert
- Lauren: Breece Hall benched behind Woody Marks
The Champ Is Starting A Dead Quarterback
Caleb Williams is listed Out and projected 0.0, and he is Beth's starting quarterback.
Beth won this entire league last year. Ten and four, first in the regular season, six straight wins to finish it, a title game taken off Lauren. She is now 2-2 holding a C and the eleventh-ranked draft, and her starting quarterback Thursday is Caleb Williams, listed Out, projected 0.0. The defending champion is fielding a man who is not going to play football. Sam LaPorta is still in there too, in a league that has never had a tight end slot and did not grow one overnight, and Ja'Marr Chase is Questionable on top of it, so the floor underneath this lineup is a hole. Nicole has Jahmyr Gibbs at 32.0, the largest number anybody puts on the field this week, plus Ashton Jeanty and 544.12 points for. Banners don't throw passes. Nicole by seventeen.
Beth won the only 2025 meeting 93.58-77.54. Projected 136.9 to 120.4, Nicole by 16.5. Beth: a starting quarterback listed Out at 0.0, a tight end in a no-tight-end league, C draft grade, eleventh. Nicole: Gibbs projected 32.0, 544.12 points for, second in the league.Tale of the tape
| 136.9 | Projected | 120.4 |
| A- | Draft grade | C |
| 7-7 | 2025 record | 10-4 |
| 9th | 2025 finish | 1st |
| 107.8 | 2025 avg | 118.0 |
| 0 | Empty slots | 0 |
Lineup alert
- Beth: starting Caleb Williams (Out)
Chris Finally Signed A Kicker And Is Favored
Four weeks of screaming at him worked, and his reward is being the favorite over a playoff team from last season.
Chris signed a kicker. Four straight weeks this page begged him and on October 1st he took Jason Myers and the Chicago defense and started fielding nine men like a functioning adult, and his reward is being favored over a team that made the winners bracket last year. He is 1-3 and he is the favorite, which says less about Chris than it does about Ben. Ben dropped De'Von Achane for Keaton Mitchell, and Mitchell is in the lineup Thursday at 12.4, next to Saquon Barkley at 0.0, next to George Kittle and Trey McBride, two tight ends, in a league with no tight end slot, for 105.8 projected. Joe Burrow sits on his bench at 19.8 while Brock Purdy starts at 17.4. Chris still has Kenneth Walker in his lineup and Kansas City is on bye this week, with MarShawn Lloyd sitting right behind him at 11.1, so nobody here is clean. Chris by nine.
Ben won the only 2025 meeting 151.02-140.76. Projected 114.8 to 105.8, Chris by 9.0. Ben: Achane dropped for Keaton Mitchell, Saquon at 0.0, two tight ends starting, Burrow benched at 19.8. Chris: Kenneth Walker starting on his bye with MarShawn Lloyd at 11.1 behind him.Tale of the tape
| 114.8 | Projected | 105.8 |
| C+ | Draft grade | B |
| 4-10 | 2025 record | 7-7 |
| 10th | 2025 finish | 4th |
| 107.5 | 2025 avg | 132.4 |
| 0 | Empty slots | 0 |
Lineup alert
- Chris: starting Kenneth Walker (on bye)
- Chris: MarShawn Lloyd benched behind Kenneth Walker
- Chris: Matthew Golden benched behind Courtland Sutton
- Chris: Tyjae Spears benched behind Kenneth Walker
- Ben: Joe Burrow benched behind Brock Purdy

Three Zeroes And Seventy-Eight Points
Fifth straight week with a man on injured reserve in the lineup, and now he has company.
Five weeks. Jordyn Tyson is still on injured reserve, still in Ally's starting lineup, still projected 0.0, and this week he has brought friends: Tetairoa McMillan and Travis Kelce, both on bye, both still starting. Carolina and Kansas City are not playing football this week and nobody has told Ally. Three starters, three zeroes, two tight ends in a league that starts none, 78.0 projected points for an entire roster. Seventy-eight. The robot handed her a D, ranked her twelfth, and she has made zero transactions all season, which stopped being laziness around week three and is now a position she holds. Jared, the dumbass who writes this page, is starting Tyler Shough at 16.0 with Jayden Daniels at 19.8 on his own bench, so he is not clean either. He is just the one playing a team that brought seventy-eight points to a gunfight. Jared by fifty-three, the week's widest gap, and he earned none of it.
Jared won the only 2025 meeting 116.34-100.02. Projected 131.3 to 78.0, Jared by 53.3, the widest margin on the board. Ally: three starters who will score nothing, McMillan and Kelce on bye plus a fifth straight week of an injured reserve receiver, zero transactions all season, D draft grade. Jared: Jayden Daniels benched at 19.8.Tale of the tape
| 131.3 | Projected | 78.0 |
| A- | Draft grade | D |
| 7-7 | 2025 record | 4-10 |
| 8th | 2025 finish | 11th |
| 113.0 | 2025 avg | 104.1 |
| 0 | Empty slots | 0 |
Lineup alert
- Jared: Jayden Daniels benched behind Tyler Shough
- Ally: starting Tetairoa McMillan (on bye)
- Ally: starting Jordyn Tyson (IR)
- Ally: starting Travis Kelce (on bye)
DEF Kansas City Chiefs · BYEMahomes Is On Bye. Joey Is Starting Him.
Joey is 0-4 with the most points against in the league, and his starting quarterback's team has the week off.
The man who runs this league is 0-4 and has given up 591.76 points, more incoming fire than anyone else in this league this season, and his starting quarterback right now is Patrick Mahomes, who is on bye, while Justin Herbert sits on his bench at 15.7. Kansas City does not play this week. That has been on the schedule since May. Pick 126, the best value of the entire draft, parked in the lineup for a week his team has off, by the guy who enforces the rules. He is also running Jacory Croskey-Merritt at 12.3 with Ollie Gordon at 17.1 and Rhamondre Stevenson at 16.3 behind him, so that's three decisions all pointing at the same shit outcome. Holli's own defense is Kansas City, same bye, same zero, which any other week would be this whole paragraph, and this week it doesn't crack Joey's top five problems. Joey beat her twice last year and then lost to her in the playoffs anyway. Both of them have until kickoff to fix it and only one of them is 0-4. Holli by twenty-one. Team Ass, 0-5.
Joey 2-1 head to head in 2025: 120.82-93.62 and 131.94-118.28, then 167.8-150.92 to Holli in the winners bracket. Projected 133.0 to 111.7, Holli by 21.3. Joey: Mahomes starting on his bye, Herbert benched at 15.7, 591.76 points against, 0-4. Holli: 3-1, W2, 389.26 against, Chiefs defense on bye.Tale of the tape
| 111.7 | Projected | 133.0 |
| B- | Draft grade | B |
| 8-6 | 2025 record | 8-6 |
| 5th | 2025 finish | 3rd |
| 120.1 | 2025 avg | 118.9 |
| 0 | Empty slots | 0 |
Lineup alert
- Joey: starting Patrick Mahomes (on bye)
- Joey: Ollie Gordon benched behind Jacory Croskey-Merritt
- Joey: Justin Herbert benched behind Patrick Mahomes
- Joey: Rhamondre Stevenson benched behind Jacory Croskey-Merritt
- Holli: starting Kansas City Chiefs (on bye)
- Holli: Stefon Diggs benched behind Ladd McConkey
- Holli: Deebo Samuel benched behind Ladd McConkey